PDA

View Full Version : A Suggestion That We Ban Together


Cynthia
01-10-2006, 12:14 PM
Ladies and Gentlemen,

I have been following the discussions in this group for quite some time and have done a bit of posting of my own. I read Joe's recent thread about clinical trials with great interest. In that exchange, a number of folks discussed the utter frustrations we have all encountered during our journeys to combat breast cancer. The devastating diagnosis and treatment process is just the beginning; we must then frequently do battle with our insurance companies, employers and oncologists. Those of us who take the time to read, research and stay informed often find ourselves shut out from clinical trials that are testing promising drugs because of this or that exclusion. Bottom line, we need help. I firmly believe that the help has to start somewhere and where better than right here.

This website is remarkable because of the extraordinary men and women who contribute to it regularly. The collective intelligence, strength and determination of the breast cancer patients and loved ones who participate here truly could move mountains. I propose we join together to channel our talents, experience and frustrations towards achieving some real results. I would personally like to join the ranks of the many who are now out there fighting for us and would encourage anyone else who is so inclined to do the same. How? I’m not sure, but that is where each of you comes in. I would really appreciate your input as to how we can best help ourselves.

Allow me to tell you a bit about me. I am a private sector attorney and a partner in law firm in Washington, DC. My world was rocked three years ago when I was diagnosed at 43 with breast cancer; 4 positive nodes; Her2+++; ER+/PR+. My husband and I had returned four months prior from China having just adopted our only child (I took my suspicious lump to a breast “specialist” several times prior to the adoption but was told repeatedly that it was “just a cyst” -- another story for another time). Given that survival was my only option, I decided to tackle my breast cancer aggressively. I opted for a bilateral mastectomy with reconstruction, six months of chemotherapy and seven weeks of radiation. When my periods returned, I had my ovaries removed so that I could take Arimidex. I applied for and was accepted into the E75 vaccine trial at Walter Reed (my husband is retired military so I qualified to receive it there). After the results of the Herceptin trials were made known, I launched a personal crusade to get it. My oncologist was not onboard because I was then fourteen months out from chemo, but, after surveying oncologists across the country, I engaged the services of one who was and I now receive it every three weeks. I also insist upon regular PET/CT screenings in the absence of symptoms and am heading off on Friday for another brain MRI after prevailing upon the more sympathetic of my two oncologists to order one for me. So far, so good.


My legal career has exposed me to a variety of advocacy tasks. I worked in Southern California for ten years representing large property owners and cities relative to complex real estate projects. I relocated with my husband to the Washington, DC area about 11 years ago where I began working with banks and trade associations regarding a variety of litigation and regulatory matters. I have spent a good portion of my career traveling the country to stomp through the halls of courthouses and governmental regulators advocating for this and that. While I do not have a background in medical lobbying per se, I believe my personal experiences with breast cancer more than qualifies me for the job. Thus, I would like to marry my legal and advocacy experiences with my passion for all things breast cancer-related to help us all fight for what we need. I would be greatly honored if you would join me.

Thankfully, there is a great deal of money being raised and spent towards research that we pray will someday slay the breast cancer beast. Until that day arrives, however, more must be done for those of us who are literally fighting for our lives. Given the statistic that 1 out of 8 women will receive a breast cancer diagnosis in her lifetime, our numbers are huge and growing every day. We need a really loud voice, but no one can scream alone. So where do we go from here? I am not at all sure, but that is where you come in because we are a work in progress.

First, we need to fully understand who is already out there doing what. For example, the National Breast Cancer Coalition (NBCC) is a Washington, DC advocacy group. I would greatly appreciate your views on what they are doing. ASCO is another powerful association, but the primary interests it serves are those of the oncologists. The Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation and the Avon Foundation Breast Cancer Crusade are huge fundraising machines, but are not themselves lobbying organizations. The Abigail Alliance recently introduced a bill that would allow patients who have run out of options access to developmental drugs outside of the clinical trial setting, though this legislation is being actively opposed by the NBCC, and does not appear to have great vocal support.

Second, we need to identify what it is that we need to achieve. For example, what do we need from the FDA, our insurers, oncologists and lawmakers?

Third, how do we achieve our goals? Do we start our own organization or do we piggyback off the infrastructure of others who are already up and running?

Fourth, contacts, contacts, contacts. Everything that gets done in politics (local and federal) comes down to contacts. So I suggest we identify the key players in the network and determine how best to approach them in an organized fashion.

Fifth, how do we fund our efforts? The only thing more important than contacts in this town is money (since money has a remarkable way of getting those contacts to return our phone calls).

Prior to throwing myself into this project with a vengeance, I would greatly appreciate your feedback. Do you perceive a need, and if so, please let me know how you would like to help. The Internet connects us all so closely that we need not limit ourselves geographically in any way.


Thank you for whatever comments you may wish to offer. If you would like to communicate with me privately, please do so at clgilman1@yahoo.net.

Fight on,

Cynthia

Cynthia
01-10-2006, 12:51 PM
Correction: My email address is clgilman1@yahoo.com (not .net).

Cynthia

AlaskaAngel
01-10-2006, 01:01 PM
Cynthia,

It is a hallmark of this website that we do have such an extraordinary collection of voices who have chosen to be here and to return here and yours is no exception.

I have been impressed with all that Joe and Christine have been able to do, not only in creating and maintaining the website but also in their continuing efforts to create and directly interact in different situations with the people who can make a difference in what happens to many of us. It is my personal opinion that likely they advocate for some of our issues more often than it may seem. I may have been a little too vocal at times with my opinions and experiences, but despite that this forum has remained completely open to me, with compassion and understanding.

I am not so trusting as to believe that getting action happens just through good intentions alone, but my feeling would be that a good place to start might be for you to have a one-on-one discussion with Joe and Christine, as they have a lot of history and experience in approaching these problems too.

AlaskaAngel

tammymarie1971
01-10-2006, 01:16 PM
Wow, Cynthia..You sure sound like someone who could make things happen!!!and also have the resources. I don't have alot to offer except personal experience, and I am in Canada so I don't know how I could help, but I am passionate about this cause..as my life depends on it, So I am willing to do whatever I can.
Tammy

CLTann
01-10-2006, 04:40 PM
We are fortunate to have people like you in our group. In order to make our effort useful for each of our diverse members, we need to recognize that there are myriads of issues that come to the discussion group. Our objectives should be to give fellow breast cancer patients comfort, information, recent medical reports, how to deal with doctors, insurance, hospital, etc., actual experience from survivors and to show them where to go.

We visited many other breast cancer support sites but this one is much more informative and caring. Although we jointed this group only a few month, we already know that a few hard working people really made the difference. Any organization can only be successful if there are dedicated people who are willing to take time to give advice and hold hands with so many of us who received the shocking news and knew no where to turn.

Therefore, I propose that some thoughts should be given to a rough idea how we can organize us into a functional group that can give person-to-person help where help is needed. Perhaps we need to organize to have several sub-groups with different disciplines. Offhand, I can see that we need a group to deal with people coming here with a diagnosis and a treatment plan. We do not advocate us as a medical facility, but with our vast resource we certainly can be in a position to show how some of us with similar situations had already dealt with the problem before. Most breast patients are much more comfortable in knowing how other fellow patients had gone through on a personal basis.

I can see that we need a group to deal with medical professionals insurance people and employers. Many of us are quite successful in dealing with these people but there are also, for a variety of reasons, many who got no where with them. I suppose an organized group could use our banded power to help out.

Then there is a need for dietary and non-traditional supplements advisory. So many postings are here that would take hours to digest and some of them are confusing and contradictory.

Of course, the information on new medication and reports on new procedures and new trial data are always eagerly waited by our members. More importantly, the interpretation of data to a common layman's language is much more useful. Most patients listen to the short and terse advice from their doctors with no intelligent questions to ask. We should get them prepared on a list of questions so that they can bring with them to the doctors. They would feel more comfortable in making a suitable choice of the options. The possible entry to the available trials should always be posted regularly for our members.

Being an aggressive type of breast cancer, HER2 positive cancer patients are always wary of recurrence. An advisory group with experience in detecting, treating and combating metastasis is badly needed by this group. How frequent should we make self-examination, take various medical tests of various organs and look for suspicious pain, itch or other symptoms?

There are many more areas that can be critically important to us. Let all of us pour in here with ideas and needs. I know we can be a meaningful force in the fight against our common enemy.

Ann

RobinP
01-11-2006, 06:50 AM
Cynthia, I admire your background and your willingness to try to change the stagnant status quo system of lack of access to more non-FDA approved breast cancer medical therapies. The only system in place at this point in time for such inaccessible experimental drugs is via of pharmaceutical company compassionate use programs. I guess I would recommend using systems that would be in place already such as compassionate use programs and work at making them more efficient, ig. speeding up the ability to obtain compasssionate use meds.I also wonder if "fast track medical approval" by the FDA could be sped up even faster to make some of these medications available to those who are literally dying to have them.

If you are looking for support, this group is a good place to start. However, for such a committed organization that you need to form, I imagine face to face interactions would be much more effective. Good luck with your endevours.

PS. I hope, especially as an attorney, you litigated for your misdiagnosis of a breast cancer. Sorry to hear about that!

michele u
01-11-2006, 09:41 AM
Cynthia,

I am a RN and would love to help you with this mission. I too agree with everything you said. WE as survivors should be able to choose for ourselves what trials we would like to participate in. There has been so many stories of people that have had their lives saved from clinical trials. But what about the people that see the EXCLUSION list and their heart's sink! We as survivors need to fight for what we want!!

Cynthia
01-12-2006, 12:09 PM
Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond to my earlier post, both here and via email. I read every response with great interest and, when the time is right, fully intend to call on those who (perhaps foolishly) offered their services.

I am currently immersed in the due diligence process to see what is out there and where I believe we can best expend our efforts. I will keep you posted on my progress. In the meantime, I encourage an ongoing discussion about what we can do to help each other and where we should focus our energies to maximize the return on our investments.

Thank you all again.

Cynthia