the day has finally come--- benefit evaluated of herceptin+lapatinib WITHOUT CHEMO!!

[Lani]

Certain breast cancer patients may benefit from combined HER-2 targeted treatment without chemotherapy
[Baylor College of Medicine]
HOUSTON — (April 8, 2013) — Is the era of targeted therapy for breast cancer at hand? It could be, said experts at the Lester and Sue Smith Breast Center at Baylor College of Medicine - at least for a certain population of women.

In a report that appears online today in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, the researchers have shown that a subset of breast cancer patients who have tumors overexpressing a protein called the human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER-2 positive) may benefit from a combination of targeted treatments that zero in on the breast cancer cells themselves. That could enable some women to avoid the "sledgehammer" of typical chemotherapy drugs that kill normal and tumor cells alike and avoid triggering resistance in tumor cells.

New era of cancer medicine

"This study really epitomizes the whole new era of cancer medicine, using effective targeted treatments against selected subsets of patients resulting in high efficacy," said Dr. Mothaffar Rimawi, medical director of the Smith Breast Center and first author on the study. "If we can efficiently target factors important to an individual's tumor, we can shut down the cancer. If we are not efficient, we are training the tumors to be resistant and develop other tumor drivers."

"By using two drugs that target the HER-2 pathway, we can attack the tumor in multiple ways and shut down its growth," said Rimawi.

The clinical trial (TBCRC 006) involved 64 women with large tumors that tested positive for HER-2 and some that were also estrogen-receptor positive. Using two drugs - lapatinib (brand name Tykerb®) and trastuzumab (brand name Herceptin®) - that target HER-2 in different ways, physicians were able to eliminate all clinical evidence of the disease in 36 percent of estrogen-receptor negative patients and 21 percent of estrogen receptor-positive patients, the researchers reported. Patients whose tumors tested positive for the estrogen receptor which meant that their tumor grew in response to the female hormone received another drug called an aromatase inhibitor to stop production of estrogen.

Preclinical models developed at BCM

"We have shown in the laboratory that complete blockage of the HER-2 family including HER-1, 2 and 3 with the drugs lapatinib and trastuzumab leads to eradication of HER-2 positive tumors in mice," said Rimawi."These drugs alone only partially inhibit the pathway, quickly resulting in resistance to treatment."

Rimawi developed this model in 2004 as a fellow in the laboratory of Dr. C. Kent Osborne, director of both the Smith Breast Center and the NCI-designated Dan L. Duncan Cancer Center at BCM and the co-senior author on the report, and Dr. Rachel Schiff, associate professor in the Smith Breast Center, also a co-author on the paper.

Over the last 10 years, researchers have tested both targeted drugs - lapatinib and trastuzumab - in studies in the patients. In the laboratory, Rimawi and colleagues demonstrated that the two drugs would likely work better when used together.

The research team at BCM sought to translate these findings to patients, so they initiated a multicenter clinical trial through the Translational Breast Cancer Research Consortium.

Rimawi and his team observed that tumors disappeared in many patients in this clinical trial, just as they had in the laboratory animals, said Osborne.

Study design

The trial involved patients from the Smith Breast Center (at the Baylor Clinic and the Harris Health System's Ben Taub Hospital sites), the Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, the University of Alabama at Birmingham, the University of Chicago and the Mayo Clinic College of Medicine.

The patients had large HER-2 positive tumors in the breast when they were initially diagnosed. They received a combination of lapatinib daily and trastuzumab (Herceptin®) once weekly for 12 weeks before surgery. They did not receive standard anti-cancer drugs. Lapatinib is a pill that blocks the enzyme activity of HER-2 and its close family member HER-1. Trastuzumab is an antibody administered intravenously that blocks HER-2 in a different way.

"With this combination, we are able to block all of the cancer-promoting signals from the HER family, which we know is crucial for growth of this kind of breast cancer," said Osborne. "Each of these drugs hits a different receptor, thereby shutting down the pathway responsible for the breast cancer's growth."

Study results

After 12 weeks, 36 percent of the estrogen-receptor negative, HER-2 positive patients had eradication of invasive breast cancer, which is ""he type of breast cancer that can spread beyond your breast and invade healthy, surrounding tissue, and other organs," said Rimawi.

A significant benefit was also observed in the estrogen-receptor positive group, Rimawi said. "Twenty-one percent of these patients had complete disappearance of their tumors and another 33 percent had near eradication with only small amounts of tumor left after treatment."

"We have seen similar results in other recently reported studies using the lapatinib/trastuzumab combination, but this is the first study not to use chemotherapy," said Osborne. "The side effects of chemotherapy can be significant and eliminating the need for chemotherapy in certain patients would represent a groundbreaking approach to treatment."

The women in the study were ethnically and racially diverse, with 33 percent Hispanic and 21 percent African-American.

Next steps in research

"Our next step with this research will be to determine the optimal duration of treatment," said Rimawi. Studies are underway now to identify which patients can be safely treated without chemotherapy for this subtype of breast cancer.

Others who took part in this study include Dr. Ingrid A. Mayer of Vanderbilt University; Dr. Andres Forero of the University of Alabama Birmingham; Dr. Rita Nanda of the University of Chicago; Dr. Matthew P. Goetz of the Mayo Clinic; Drs. Angel A. Rodriguez and Jenny Chang from the Methodist Hospital; Anne C. Pavlick, Tao Wang, Dr. Susan G. Hilsenbeck and Dr. Carolina Gutierrez, all of BCM. This study was supported by GlaxoSmithKline (www.gsk.com) and the Translational Breast Cancer Research Consortium.

ABSTRACT: Multicenter Phase II Study of Neoadjuvant Lapatinib and Trastuzumab With Hormonal Therapy and Without Chemotherapy in Patients With Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2-Overexpressing Breast Cancer: TBCRC 006
[Journal of Clinical Oncology]
Purpose: We previously reported the eradication of human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)-amplified human xenografts in mice by inhibition of the HER2 pathway with lapatinib and trastuzumab to block all homo- and heterodimer signaling as well as by blockade of estrogen receptor (ER) when expressed. In this clinical trial, we sought to translate these findings to patients using targeted therapy without chemotherapy.

Patients and Methods Women with stages II to III HER2-positive breast cancers were eligible. They received trastuzumab once per week (4 mg/kg loading, then 2 mg/kg) and lapatinib 1000 mg once per day for 12 weeks. Women with ER-positive tumors also received letrozole (plus a luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone [LHRH] agonist if premenopausal). Pathologic response was assessed by ER status. Biopsies were obtained at baseline, weeks 2 and 8, and time of surgery.

Results: Sixty-six patients were enrolled, and 64 were eligible and evaluable for response. Median tumor size was 6 cm (range, 1.5 to 30 cm). Adverse events were mainly grades 1 to 2 (GI, 63%; skin, 46%). Grade 3 metabolic, GI, and liver (18%; 12 patients) and grade 4 liver toxicities (one patient) were also observed. Overall, in-breast pathologic complete response (pCR; ypT0-is) was 27% (ER positive, 21%; ER negative, 36%). The rate of low-volume residual disease (ypT1a-b) was 22% (ER positive, 33%; ER negative, 4%).

Conclusion: In patients with locally advanced HER2-positive breast cancer, our approach of targeted therapy only resulted in a high pCR rate without chemotherapy. Our data support the hypothesis that selected patients with HER2-positive tumors may not need chemotherapy, and more-complete blockade of HER receptors and ER is an effective strategy worthy of further study.

[SoCalGal]

And I love that the study used only 1000 mg of Tykerb (4pills) verses 5 pills. MUCH easier to tolerate when pooperia strikes.

[KDR]

Just out of curiosity, how many were maintained on this regimen here WITHOUT chemo?

This would be my dream combo, but I progressed on it WITH Xeloda. Rats!

Karen

[Ceesun]

I was on tykerb/hercep for 32 months remaining stable or shrinking until I had to switch to something else!

[Andrea Barnett Budin]

A sISTER I HAVE HAD THE JOY OF MEETING W/IN CALIF AND CHATTERING W/ OVER A 3 HR LUNCH SOME YRS BACK, WAS IN THE INITIAL CLINICAL TRIALS.

SHE COULDN'T TOLERATE THE TAXANE AND SO WENT ON WITH ONLY HERCEPTIN.

SHE HAS NOT RECURRED AT LEAST DURING HER 10 YRS ON HERCEPTIN. WE LAUGHED SAYING, WE WERE PREPARED TO STAY ON VIT H FOREVERRRRRRRRRRR. WHEN I QUIT I FOUND SHE HAD QUIT A YR BEFORE ME. AND AS FAR AS I KNOW, SHE REMAINS STABLE.

I'VE BEEN OFF H FOR ALMOST 5 YRS. STABLE...

BIG WOW!!!

Andi

[Jen]

Oh how I wish this would been available to my Mother, Sheila when she was initially diagnosed who knows maybe she would still be here....

[michka]

It didn't work for me. Michka

[Andrea Barnett Budin]

I wish H worked for every one of us.

For me, adding the supplements and meditation helped big time.

Every cancer is different. Every person, every body is different. There is no simple across the board treatment for us all. Variations have to be tried. And that sucks.

It is my fervent prayer we each find our perfect recipe.

I do wholeheartedly believe since our immune systems become so damaged and compromised on chemo, we must do more to boost it up.

I wish Sheila were still with us. And Brenda. And so many who I've known and loved and miss with all my heart.

['lizbeth]

5 years ago I search online for months trying to find a clinical trial like this for me. I can't believe I'm finally reading about a study without chemo.

Lani, you have made my day.

[Barbara H.]

I have been on Herceptin and Tyberb since I went off the TDM-1 trial at the end of 2009. I only take 4 tablets. I find this combination very easy to tolerate and it is working for me.
Best,
Barbara H.

[JillaryJill]

Great news...now if a vaccine would work to prevent breast cancer in the first place.!

[Mtngrl]

My oncologist said she thinks it's important to avoid chemo with HER-2 cancer (even though I got it for 12 weeks--that was standard of care at the time.) Charging up the immune system and teaching it to eliminate the HER family of proteins looks more and more like the thing to do.

[Mandamoo]

That's interesting Amy. My Onc feels I will never have time off chemo. The one time I had a break was last year for about six weeks - I took tykerb daily and had a loading dose of herceptin prior to my holiday - my cancer doubled in size in that time. I a, hoping the herceptin and perjeta alone may be an option for me for a while after this carboplatin has had a go.

[CoolBreeze]

The only time I had regression was Gemzar and Perjeta. And, I started them both at the same time. Who knows which one did it? Or both? My doctor also feels I will never be off chemo - interesting to hear about one who disagrees. Would like to hear more about that.

Gemzar is very hard on me so I wish I could stay on Perjeta/Herpetin but am not going to play with success, even if it makes my life much harder. Hope they find out for sure soon though!