[Jackie07]

Another study has shown better result of CSA. As the study concludes, “CSA guided chemotherapy should be compared to empiric treatment by a prospective randomized trial.”

Pol Przegl Chir. 2013 Jun 1;85(6):340-7. doi: 10.2478/pjs-2013-0051.

In Vitro Chemo-Sensitivity Assay Guided Chemotherapy is Associated with Prolonged Overall Survival in Cancer Patients.

Udelnow A, Schönfelder M, Würl P, Halloul Z, Meyer F, Lippert H, Mroczkowski P.

Abstract

The aim of the study.
The overall survival (OS) of patients suffering From various tumour entities was correlated with the results of in vitro-chemosensitivity assay (CSA) of the in vivo applied drugs.

Material and methods.
Tumour specimen (n=611) were dissected in 514 patients and incubated for primary tumour cell culture.
The histocytological regression assay was performed 5 days after adding chemotherapeutic substances to the cell cultures. n=329 patients undergoing chemotherapy were included in the in vitro/in vivo associations. OS was assessed and in vitro response groups compared using survival analysis. Furthermore Cox-regression analysis was performed on OS including CSA, age, TNM classification and treatment course.

Results.
The growth rate of the primary was 73-96% depending on tumour entity. The in-vitro response rate varied with histology and drugs (e.g. 8-18% for methotrexate and 33-83% for epirubicine). OS was significantly prolonged for patients treated with in vitro effective drugs compared to empiric therapy (log-rank-test, p=0.0435). Cox-regression revealed that application of in vitro effective drugs, residual tumour and postoperative radiotherapy determined the death risk independently.

Conclusions.
When patients were treated with drugs effective in our CSA, OS was significantly prolonged compared to empiric therapy. CSA guided chemotherapy should be compared to empiric treatment by a prospective randomized trial.