Too old for Chemo
 

It started as a small spot on my back, basil cell, which led to HER2 positive. The lumpectomy indicated the tumor to be very small (1.5x1 cm) and no trace of cancer in the 13 lymph nodes removed. I felt very lucky. The radiation doctor said I had a 10 year 96% survival with chemo and 93% with radiation. At 74 years old, it was a no brainer. Then I saw the chemo doctor. He said my cancer was very aggressive and I should have chemo. He wanted a Oncotype DX Breast test, but my insurance said it had to be HER2 negative before they would cover it. I see him Monday. All of the discussions have been about chemo. Is there anyone who has suggestions for me? I would like radiation with Herceptin shots.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Her2 breast cancer is very aggressive and chemo is always recommended especially if the tumor is over 1 cm such as yours. However, your idea of Herceptin only may be a viable one but there have been no studies that this works. Is your tumor also estrogen and/or progesterone positive as well? If so, there are studies with metastatic patients (Stage 4 and you are Stage 1) that shows there is good synergy with Herceptin and an aromatase inhibitor together. I am just thinking out loud here. If the oncologist you see is not keen on Herceptin alone without chemo, see another. Not too many doctors want to do something that is not standard of care but you can get a second opinion and you should anyway so set up another opinion asap. We are here for you throughout your journey.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

I second Becky's opinion. And offer this:
Throw at this bugger every single thing you can at the very very beginning. Postpone nothing. Get rid of your breast. Take no prisoners. please visit the staging polls threads. A person can start off with a tiny tiny stage one and move to stage three or possibly stage four in months. Not often. But it happens. Put on your battlegear. Welcome to the war. This is your life we're talking about.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

If you are wondering, because the original trials for adjuvant treatment were done using chemo + trastuzumab, we do not know which patients may benefit from using trastuzumab alone and which patients likely do not.

One reason why the benefit of chemo may be less for elderly patients is because they are generally postmenopausal. One of the main effects of chemotherapy is to bring on menopause in older patients.

If you are interested, check out the clinical trials below.

Trials offered at present to try to determine what the benefit is OR is not for elderly HER2 positive patients:

http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/N...elderly&rank=2

http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/N...elderly&rank=6

http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/N...elderly&rank=1

We won't know unless we try to find out.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

IMHO, the docs are expert in their areas - the rad onc is the radiation onc. He knows all about radiation. The medical onc. (chemo) onc. knows all about meds - chemo, Tamoxifen, AIs etc. Her 2 is very aggressive, Nordko is right -hit it with everything you can on your first (and hopefully only) shot out there.... If you are ER+PR+ too, then see what the med. onc. has to say about AIs like Femara etc.

They will check out your heart function with a Muga scan or echo for Herceptin. Don't think that because you are 74 you should take the "easy" way out. I know an 80 year old woman who was Her2+ and did chemo and Herceptin. She did fine. Get a second opinion as Becky suggests - from a medical onc. You need rads for sure because you had a lumpectomy. I went full tilt and had a mastectomy and did not need rads because my 16 lymph nodes were all clear.

Good luck. We are here for you. You are a Warrior Woman now.

all the best
caya

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

I agree with all the above and would urge you to look at all your options.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

"Then I saw the chemo doctor. He said my cancer was very aggressive and I should have chemo. He wanted a Oncotype DX Breast test, but my insurance said it had to be HER2 negative before they would cover it."

Why would an expert like a chemo doctor recommend the Oncotype DX testing when the insurance company only pays for such a test if the patient is HER2 negative? Is it because the insurance company considers the HER2 positive diagnosis to be absolutely indicative of the importance of chemotherapy, but the oncologist doesn't?

???

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Don't accept that you are too old for chemo. What is important is your health before BC. If your heart is OK and if you feel OK then you should be considered like any woman. HER2 is aggressive. There are discussions for stage I but not for the others. It is the only discussion to have with your onc. There may also be an option of chemo-30% dosage although, as it has already been said here, oncs like to stick to standards. But most important, it is Your decision after being informed of the benefits/risks. Herceptin should be considered. Michka

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Every response is so appreciated. I am so confused by the names and abbreviations, but it seems that chemo is what I have to do. "keep informed" on what? Do I look up every medicine, every reaction is different. Do I ask a doctor from the same group for an opinion, or go somewhere else? My family says no to chemo - they know less than I. At this point I just want to get something started. My emotions are in control.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Judieru,

Anyone who has been through this understands that there are no hard and fast rules or garanteed outcomes. Everyone here would like to have a way to make the choice based on a definite clear basis.

However, the person that "does the most toxic treatment" in fact may recur. The tendency among health care providers and patients is to lean more in the direction of caution. It really depends on your own personal level of risk tolerance, combined with as much as you are able to determine about how high the estimate is about your risk level. Different medical institutions and practitioners sometimes vary in their approach in deciding which patients get which treatments. There are two main bodies that provide guidelines. One is used more in the US, and the other is used more in Europe and the rest of the world. The NCCN guidelines are the ones most commonly used in the US. You may want to check out the guidelines offered in Europe as well.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Hi Judie -
Just stopped in here to help point you, as one can bat around looking at cancer sites forever!
NCCN stands for National Comprehensive Cancer Network.
Here is the link where you will find info on the specific subtypes of breast cancer - yes, SUBtypes. Clink on Breast cancer and some choices will appear. Check those.

http://www.nccn.org/professionals/ph...nes.asp#breast

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

The European one is the St. Gallen breast cancer conference.

It is interesting to see how much the highly experienced and trained professional opinions vary when coming up with recommendations for guidelines, no matter which set of guidelines is used:

http://www.sisbreast.org/Material/Ar.../consensus.pdf

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

I am strong, I can handle migraines so I can handle side effects of chemo. We will beat this.
My wonderful husband and two daughters went with me for the results of the DX - high risk, 67%, for such a small tumor and clear lymph nodes. Ecg Wednesday, port after Thanksgiving, start 90 min of Herceptin on Dec 9. then TCH (taxotere, cyoxan ,herceptin) every 3 weeks for 6 months.
6 weeks of radiation, Herceptin for 12 months and Arimidex for 10 years. We will tour the US in our RV before we leave.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Sounds like you've got your personal sense of direction in gear for the next decade of treatment - Best wishes!

A.A.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Judieru!!!! YAAAAAHOOOOOO! I am so so proud of you. I applaud your excellent decision to live!!!! You will live for many may years more because of toughing out a wittle belly ache for four months! Ask for Emend, get the doctor on call to write a prescription for it. it's not covered, but it will absolutely prevent nausea, guaranteed. take it in the car on the way home. yes it is expensive but i guarantee you will be happy you did. I am laughing at my sayin "wittle belly ache" in light of how angry and crazy the steroids they give you during chemo make one sometimes....come here for advice on how to tolerate the bone pain...i had none during the taxotere (or equivalent) second half of my chemo co of taking preventative ibuprofen (Advil) and Vitamins A and E, I think it was....while others went crazy with bone pain, i.e. Denise.

I adore what you said about how well you have gotten through tough things in your life like migraine, so what's one more tough thing to be a hero through? Atta girl!!! Seventy four is young. Radio said the other day it's now ninety that women live to on average. I am so happy for you. Because of gutting this out early in the game you have a great chance, please God, of living to see your grandkids graduate! Well done girl~~ Stay strong and ask us any question at all no matter how embarrassing, etc...we are here for you.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Great plan Judieru - you can do it- sounds like you have great support with DH and DDs.

Take the anti-nausea meds before you actually start feeling nauseous - you don't want to play "catch up" with that feeling.

all the best
caya

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

Thanks girls, I don't know if I should cry, or just go to bed.
Your thoughts are a comfort to me.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

good for you! You are as young as you feel, you may, however feel a bit older 2-3 days after chemo, but as you said you are strong! My Oncologist prescribed Emend for me to take day of chemo and for the following two days. It was covered by my insurance. I only had very minimal nausea using this, I think I only took "as needed" medication ~ 3 times.
Stay strong and Be Well!

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

I have been put on hold for a while, my surgeon is on vacation and booked solid until Dec 11th for the port. Should I just look for a local surgeon to put it in and get started with the chemo? Don't like waiting and doing nothing. My husband isn't well, so we don't go anywhere. I am trying to keep busy with sewing and getting ready for tax season (I volunteer for that), and think I should eat anything in sight. I want to sleep whenever I'm not eating, everything is confusing.

Re: Too old for Chemo
 

I am surprised that your surgeon has put you off for so long. Installing a port is a very short procedure and should be able to be fit in before 12/11. If they really can't get you in before that, I would certainly look for someone who could. However, I am impatient and would not be comfortable waiting.